Joined MNUFC on January 19, 2018 as the 7th overall pick in the 2018 MLS SuperDraft
Hometown: South Orange, New Jersey
MNUFC Debut: March 10, 2018 at Orlando City SC
First MNUFC Start: May 5, 2018 vs. Vancouver Whitecaps FC
First MNUFC Goal: June 18, 2019 at Houston Dynamo (USOC)
- Made 10th MLS start on September 25, 2019 vs Sporting Kansas City
- Made 30th MLS appearance on September 15, 2019 vs Real Salt Lake
- Earned his 10th MLS point with a goal against LAFC on September 1, 2019
- Became third MNUFC player to win the MLS Player of the Week Award in Week 26 of the 2019 season.
- Toye has earned MLS Team of the Week honors twice in his career, both in 2019.
- First MNUFC player to score their first goal for the club in U.S. Open cup play.
- Earned his first MLS assist in his club debut on March 10, 2018 at Orlando City SC.
- Scored his first professional goal on September 2, 2018 against LA Galaxy II while on loan with Colorado Switchbacks FC in the USL Championship.
- Led the team with three game-winning goals in 2019.
- Averaged 0.66 goals per 90 minutes played, the 10th best rate in the league in 2019.
Toye has made four appearances for the U.S. U23 men’s national team in 2019, scoring in both of his first two games.