ACQUIRED: Traded from New England on 2.15.2017
Shuttleworth was traded to MNUFC from New England Revolution on February 15, 2017. In 33 appearances (32 starts) for the Loons during the 2017 season, he managed 116 saves — second among MLS keepers on the year — five shutouts and two penalty stops.
The goalkeeper was an MLS Team of the Week member in Week 8 after making three saves en route to the Loons’ first shutout in MLS, a 1-0 result over Colorado Rapids. He earned another spot in Week 10 with a second clean sheet and third win of the campaign, notching seven saves in a 2-0 victory over Sporting Kansas City.
Shuttleworth spent eight seasons with the New England Revolution from 2009–2016, totaling 127 appearances, 124 starts, 34 shutouts, 344 saves and a 46-53-28 regular-season record. The Tonawanda, New York native anchored the Revolution during its run to the 2014 MLS Cup, tying the club record with 16 wins, and accumulated six postseason starts during the 2014 and 2015 campaigns.
He featured for three years at the University of Buffalo, starting 33 matches while maintaining a record of 20-7-7 and a goals-against average of 0.80. In high school, he set a school record with 48 career shutouts at Nichols School in Buffalo, New York, in addition to earning all-state recognition.
2018: Made first start of the year on April 22 at SEA (4 SV, 3 GA)...Earned first win of the season on April 28 vs HOU (4 SV, 1 GA)...Earned second win and first clean sheet on May 5 vs VAN (7 SV, 0 GA)...Set club record for saves in a single match on May 20 vs SKC (9SV, 1 GA)...Earned third win and second clean sheet on May 26 vs MTL (4 SV, 0 GA)...Earned fourth win on July 4 vs TOR (2 SV, 3 GA)...Earned fifth win on July 14 vs RSL (4 SV, 2 GA)...Earned sixth win on July 18 vs NE (6 SV, 1 GA)...Earned seventh win on July 22 vs LAFC (6 SV, 1 GA)...Earned eighth win on September 22 vs POR (3 SV, 2 GA)...Earned ninth win on September 29 vs NYC (2 SV, 1 GA)
2017: Made MNUFC debut as a substitute on March 12 vs ATL (0 SV, 1 GA) ... Made first start on March 18 at COL (1 SV, 2 GA) ... Earned first win of the season on April 1 vs RSL (3 SV, 2 GA). Won Save of the Week for Week 5 ... Was subbed off due to injury in the first half on April 15 at HOU (2 SV, 2 GA) ... Recorded first clean sheet in club history and earned his second win on March 23 vs COL (3 SV, 0 GA). On the bench in Week 8 MLS Team of the Week ... Earned his second clean sheet and third win on May 7 vs SKC (7 SV, 0 GA). On the bench in Week 10 MLS Team of the Week ... Earned fourth win and third clean sheet on May 27 vs ORL (7 SV, 0 GA) ... Earned fifth win on June 21 vs POR (3 SV, 2 GA) ... Earned fourth clean sheet on July 19 vs HOU (4 SV) ... Earned fifth clean sheet and sixth win on July 29 vs DC (5 SV) ... Earned seventh win on August 26 at CHI (3 SV, 1 GA) ... Made first penalty save and earned eighth win on September 16 at MTL (3 SV, 2 GA) ... Made second penalty save and earned ninth win on September 23 vs FCD (6 SV, 1 GA) ... Earned tenth win of the season on October 3 at ATL (3 SV, 2 GA)