ACQUIRED: Selected 7th overall in the 2018 MLS SuperDraft
Toye was selected seventh overall by MNUFC in the 2018 MLS SuperDraft from Indiana University. The Generation adidas forward earned tremendous accolades during his freshman year with the Hoosiers, leading the Big Ten with 10 goals on the season — including five game-winners — and adding a pair of assists to win Big Ten Freshman of the Year, first-team All-Big Ten, Big Ten All-Freshman Team and first-team United Soccer Coaches All-Midwest Region accolades. His efforts put Indiana in the 2017 NCAA National Championship final, where it fell 1-0 to Stanford in double overtime.
Before college, Toye was named first-team All-America by USA Today and New Jersey Gatorade Player of the Year, in addition to being named to the U.S. under-19 national team and training with the U20s in London. He played his high school soccer at Seton Hall Prep in West Orange, New Jersey, leading the side to its first North Jersey, Non-Public A title since 2009.
2019: Made first appearance on May 29 at ATL...Scored first MNUFC and Open Cup goal on June 18 at HOU...Scored first MLS goal and provided first assist of the year on June 29 vs CIN...Provided second assist on July 3 vs SJ...Scored second and third goals on July 6 at MTL...Scored fourth goal on July 13 vs FCD...Provided third assist on July 20 at RSL...Scored second Open Cup goal on August 7 vs POR
2018: Made his MNUFC and professional debut as a substitute and provided his first career assist on March 10 at ORL...Made first start on May 5 vs VAN...Missed May 9 at LAFC due to suspension...Scored first MNUFC goal in the Open Cup on June 18 at HOU